Read pp. 182-200 from Dr. Aram Sinnreich's book, Piracy Crusade, and use the comments section of this post to write your response to the following:
1. What is Sinnreich's main argument regarding copyright?
2. According to Sinnreich, is democracy piracy?
3. Do you think our current copyright law should be abolished? If so, which alternative system would work best? If not, provide one reason why the current law is sufficient.
4. Do you agree or disagree with Sinnreich's approach? Why?
1. Sinnreich's main Argument regarding copyright is that the sixth function of copyright is to incentivize industrial organizations to exploit creative work, thereby both spreading new ideas and generating new wealth for the economy. He also states that the problem with the piracy crusade isn't copyright per se, but rather the fact that it overwhelmingly privileges the sixth function, often to the detriment of the first five.
ReplyDelete2. According to Sinnreich the tensions at the heart of the piracy crusade are exactly the same as those at the root of the democratic process.
3. Our current copyright law should be abolished. Sinnreich said the willful blindness that leads our governments to support the anti-piracy agenda despite it's obvious flaws and faults is evidence of a genuine dysfunction within both the private organizations that lobby for these policies and the state institutions that enact them. Instead enact a binding digital bill of rights to the once promoted congressman, and to develop laws, treaties, and international policies that adhere to its principles.
1. Sinnreich's main argument regarding copyright is that because the decision has been made to fight piracy, we may be left sacrificing free speech and privacy. The policies, tightening copyright laws are threatening to undermine the foundations of our democratic society.
ReplyDelete2. Sinnreich does agree that piracy is very much so like democracy.
3. I believe that in this new age of technology and as the innovations in internet and other forms of media continue to evolve, the copyright laws are no longer sufficient. As he stated best, "We need to abandon the ideology of the anti-piracy agenda and to look with fresh eyes at the complex causal relationships among information sharing, commerce, and society".
4. I do agree with his approach. I think he addresses things from different angles. He acknowledges the changes that technology has brought, he acknowledges the financial side of the argument, and he acknowledges that we have grown accustomed to what we are used to. We need to rethink things, reflecting on the changes that have been made.
Sinnreich claims our current copyright laws and policies need to be intensely revised and modernized. He also believes there should not be a single set of rules governing information and intelligence.
ReplyDeleteAccording to Sinnreich, there are many attributes of piracy and democracy that go hand-in-hand.
We shouldn’t completely abolish copyright laws, but our current law is certainly outdated. I agree with Sinneich that “the alternative to the anti-piracy agenda isn’t simply lawlessness…” but instead we need an updated set of rules and policies regarding public information on the web. It would make sense to grant governments, markets & societies the leeway to regulate information sharing on their own terms. That or Issa’s idea of creating a “Digital Citizen’s Bill of Rights.” Both routes seem like viable options.
I agree with Sinnreich’s main argument that there needs to be a drastic change in copyright law. Technology has changed immensely, along with the sharing of intellectual property. The way we share and use others’ intellectual property technically subjects many of us to violation of the current copyright laws. As long as the person using another’s creative property gives proper credit, I believe they should legally be allowed to do so, which is why there needs to be a change in law to allow this behavior.
1.Sinnreich's main argument about copyrights was that the law is outdated and needs to be revised to some point. The law is really old and was created in an age where the internet was primitive compared to today.
ReplyDelete2. He says that hey coincide somewhat but are not exactly the same.
3. I think the copyright law needs a touch up or a revision. The law was made years ago and most laws rarely stay the same after decades. I do not know exactly how I would change it but I understand not allowing someone not to take ideas from people and plagiarize word for word. In my opinion having an artists music or an image in created content should be allowed or at least when credited. It is very complicated and I'm not an expert so it isn't simple to fix the copyright law.
4. I agree that there needs to be a change with the copyright laws we have in place today. Even if a change is made it won't last decades from now so it needs adjusted occasionally with the times.
1. Sinnreich is arguing that copyright laws need to change and keep changing as technology changes. He is also arguing against the piracy crusade saying that it is very important that we end the piracy crusade.
ReplyDelete2. Sinnerich says that the forces that drive piracy are the same as the roots of democracy. This means that democracy and piracy are similar in what drives them.
3. I think the current copyright law should be abolished. Sinnerich talks about how current copyright laws have many flaws and suggests that we enact a digital bill of rights.
4. I agree with Sinnerich, when he says that in the future the concept “copying” will have no meaning. With social media and new technologies we can see that people are already copying things in many ways.
1.Sinnreich's main argument is that we must find a steady balance when it comes to copyright. Sinnreich states that we need a balance between government regulation and commercial privatization.
ReplyDelete2.There is a clear representation that piracy and democracy can go hand in hand and sinreich makes a point to show that
3.I don't believe it should our copyright law should be abolished entirely. The purpose of our copyright law is to to promote the Progress of Science and Art, by securing Authors and Inventors the exclusive right to their respective Writings and Discoveries. However this has not been enforced. I believe there should be an updated version of the copyright law that allows and can apply to all the media and technology of today.
4. Sinnreich makes very good points and opened my eyes to information that I had not really thought about, an example would be the piracy crusade and its negative effects.
1. Sinnreich argues the laws of copyright, believing such a law must change along with the constant changes in technology. He considers the law to be outdated.
ReplyDelete2. Sinnreich explains the two are similar, for those in piracy do things secretly and in private just as the government does with international IP treaties going in effect in secrecy.
3. Our laws are outdated and should definitely be revised and updated, in my opinion. It should stay consistent with the times of technology. Perhaps like Sinnreich said, to create a digital bill of rights could possibly work as well-if not better.
4. I agree with Sinnreich, there must be change and soon. Without change, these problems will not be resolved and people will continue to do things in secrecy.
1) Sinnreich's main argument is that copyright isn't necessarily harmful but, the income of wealth that is being produced in result of the process is being directed to 3rd party people who control use of copyright.
ReplyDelete2) In the readings by Sinnreich, he states that both piracy and the bare bones of Democracy are both in similarity with each other. There for being the same.
3) I believe that the copyright law is just. Although, I believe that there should be some changes. I believe that all media should be freely used, as long as the main owner who created the source is acknowledged. What we create as human beings isn't purely original, we develop and change as we see around us. We mold and adjust to our surroundings. So, therefore as an artist when creating a piece of art, we've had previous reference in the making of this art. So, If I drew a tree and called it mine, then that tree should then earn gratuity and be acknowledged in the end.
4) Sinnreich's argument is solid, I firmly believe in the points he has made in this reading are positive changes that could enhance our society as a whole.
1. Sinnreich's main argument is that we are living in a time where it is hard to find the perfect balance between government regulation and commercial privatization. Therefore our privacy and freedom of speech has been compromised. Global corporations are in charge and are highly involved in the government.
ReplyDelete2. What I got from this article and I could be wrong is that piracy is committed as an act against democracy. If industrial lobbying is greatly embedded in the government and heavily influences our out dated copyright laws which limits our freedom of expression then piracy will take place as an act of human rights. Piracy and Democracy run parallel to each other in terms of the copyright laws.
3. I do not think that the copyright law should be abolished but I do think it should be continuously updated. I don't believe stealing someone else's work and capitalizing on it is fair but I also feel gaining inspiration from someone else's work is essential in life. The "balance" we all wish to have might not be achieved to the fullest do to Government and Corporate control but I do believe that their is hope for modification and adapting to the current world to the best ability. Keeping constant tabs and evolving efficiently would be beneficial for both parties.
4. The entire time I was reading Sinnereich's article I kept thinking of that documentary "Hot Coffee", The enforced idea that the government passes laws based on global industries and huge corporate investments. Humanity and creative expression only plays a small role even though laws such as the copyright law may falsely portray to us otherwise. Sinnereich makes excellent points, very intellectual points but I have to be honest I felt like he over exhausted his view of "things changing so rapidly" for the reasoning behind out dated laws and the government's unwillingness to change. I felt like that was a really lame excuse that he referenced more than once in his article. Our government is the highest form of decision making for our society, nothing can stop them so with that being said they should embrace change and be prepared and equipt for its arrival. If technology is changing at an overwhelmingly rapid pace then the government should assign a department that's on deck at all times, analyzing and addressing these extreme changes as they come. Maybe this already exists to some extent, but I'm assuming if it was successful this article would've never been written.
1. Sinnreich’s main argument regarding copyright is that laws should be regulated according to our times and the changes triggered by the evolution of technology, culture and industry. In the same way, the different industries (music, pharma, technology software,…) shouldn’t be controlled by the same copyright policy because each of them have different needs of regulation. By last, he argues that the problem of the piracy crusade is not the copyright per se, but the fact that it doesn’t defend the equality of all its functions, advantaging the incentivize industrial organizations function over the rest.
ReplyDelete2. I think the answer to this question is quiet ambiguous. Sinnreich ensures that the reasons of the existence of the piracy crusade are exactly the same as the root of the democratic process in a try to get and define freedom between all the conflicting needs of many stakeholders. He also says that “for a growing number of people around the world, the answers to these questions (democracy) are looking increasingly less to involve copyright and intellectual property”.
3. Not abolished, but it should be modified and updated. I think the current copyright isn’t really efficient, it doesn’t treat everyone equally favoring some more than others. On the other hand, copyright can’t be abolished because our historical experience demonstrates that in most cases, we humans, aren’t able to behave without laws and formal recognition of rights.
4. I do agree with his analysis, assessment and explanation about the need of changing the copyright law to consider the new technological, cultural and social issues, especially with the fast evolution of the Internet medium. And to look for a more common and general interest.
Sinnreich's main argument about copyright is that the copyright crusade is flimsy. He believes that organizations abuse copyright law and take away new ideas and creativity from individuals.
ReplyDeleteSinnreich does believe the democracy and piracy have a lot of fundamental similarities.
I do think are copyright laws need to change to fit the age of the internet and social media sites like twiiter, facebook, tumblr, and instagram. I believe there still needs to be protection on an individuals idea but as we were talking about the NFL taking off all football related stuff and shutting down accounts is ridiculous. There needs to be a line drawn for crediting, sharing and reposting.
I do agree with a lot of what he says about copyright. Though I think the comparison with religion threw me off slightly. He aboslutely makes sense with the sixth function getting an influx of power.
1.Sinnreich's main argument regarding copyright is that it is something that is being taken advantage for commercial use as a way to make money. He also agues that the copyright law is outdated and needs to continually be updated because of how often technology is updated and things change.
ReplyDelete2. Democracy and piracy are both two different things but there is a fine line that splits up the two, which Sinnreich talks about.
3. I do not think that our current copyright law should be abolished as so much just be revised and changed to match current times so that everyone can continue to express themselves but also get the right recognition for what they create.
4. I agree with Sinnreich's approach because he has made some very good points about an issue that I was not even aware about. The copyright law is something that should be updated before it causes further problems in society.
1. Sinnreich argues that copyright laws have not been changing and updating along with advancements in technology. He also argues that we have yet to find the balance between government regulation and commercial privatization.
ReplyDelete2. Sinnreich says that the aims of the democratic process and the piracy crusade are very similar.
3. I think that if done correctly, the copyright law serves a purpose in protecting the rights of creators and it should not be abolished completely. We should definitely continue to change and modernize copyright laws so that it can apply to our current and changing technology. A fair alternative that Sinnreich suggests is the “digital bill of rights”.
4. I agree with Sinnreich’s argument in that copyright laws have to be continually updated and modified to match our advancements in society.
1.Sinnreich believes that the copyright laws should be changed that artists should not have the right to keep being paid for their music even after there dead.
ReplyDelete2. The Piracy is like a democracy in piracy that they are the same thing.
3. I agree with the current copyright laws and copyright today because if you Paton something should that Paton go away in 10 years no.
4.I disagree with Adam Sinnreich because I strongly feel that the copyright laws should stay the same artists are entitled to be compensated for their work.